Too Much of a Good Thing? Jake Remmert on Strength Training Volume
Photo by Sven Mieke / Unsplash

Too Much of a Good Thing? Jake Remmert on Strength Training Volume

Dr. Jake Remmert, a professor and researcher at Illinois State University, joins Practically Fit to talk about his new study, “Is There Too Much of a Good Thing? Meta-Regressions of the Effect of Per-Session Volume on Hypertrophy and Strength.” Jake explains what the research found about how many sets you really need, and what it means for anyone strength training over 40.

After the interview, in a "Cool Down" segment, Abbie and I share some of our their biggest takeaways from the interview:

  • Why your first few sets do most of the work
  • How process-oriented goals can beat chasing numbers
  • Why staying healthy and consistent matters more than progression
  • How emotional intelligence makes a great coach or workout partner

In addition, we take a look at some of the latest fitness news. First up is the New York Times on “brain stacking,” the viral trend of turning puzzles and journaling into an optimized hour. Then we get into new mile world record holder Josh Kerr’s advice for recreational runners: skip the hydration vest (Josh clearly doesn't live in Texas).

Next week: a trip down fitness memory lane with some of our favorite fitness moments.

Enjoying Practically Fit? Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts. If you like what you hear, a rating or review on Apple Podcasts really helps. Get every episode and our weekly content straight to your inbox by subscribing below.

Read The Transcript

Too Much of a Good Thing? Jake Remmert on Strength Training Volume

Jake: The older we get, the more fatigue is a thing we really want to pay attention to. When we're 18, it kind of doesn't matter. Just go in and do a lot of stuff and you'll be fine. But as we get older, we've got to really start to pay attention. And so it starts to feel less and less worth it to push those really high volumes when you know you're getting such a tiny return on your big investment.

Alex: Welcome to Practically Fit, Real Fitness Over 40. I'm Alex.

Abbie: And I'm Abbie.

Alex: And today we'll be talking with Dr. Jake Remmert, a professor and researcher from Illinois State University, who recently led a study about strength training volume that's been getting a lot of media attention.

Abbie: That's right. The study is titled "Is There Too Much of a Good Thing? Meta-Regressions of the Effect of Per-Session Volume on Hypertrophy and Strength." Alex, you had the chance to interview Jake about this study and got to hear some of his practical advice, including advice for people who are strength training over 40.

Alex: Yeah, it was a great interview. We'll share it here in a moment. I recorded it last week while you were traveling, and luckily you avoided getting caught up in the ground stop, the infamous ground stop.

Abbie: Well, I very narrowly missed it. I was actually in flight when the ground stop took effect.

Alex: That's right. And I texted you about it, which you really appreciated, knowing there's no communication going on with air traffic control across the country while you were in the air.

Abbie: You know what? I talk about this all the time: sometimes ignorance is bliss, right? I've said this before about air travel, where pilots tell you information and I'm like, I didn't need to know that. Keep it to yourself. So I felt like that when Alex texted me to say there's a nationwide ground stop and I was in the air. I was like, that doesn't sound good. I don't know that I want to know about that until I've landed.

Alex: I was trying to be informative.

Abbie: I'm just teasing you. But then I did Google it and I was like, oh, this doesn't sound good. Communication issues, which I'm assuming means they can't talk to air traffic control consistently. But I was very, very fortunate in that I did land safely, and I landed just ahead of it basically becoming a parking lot at DFW.

Alex: Right. Because if you'd been on the next flight in, you'd have been stuck for like four and a half hours on the tarmac.

Abbie: Definitely.

Alex: I hope nobody got caught up in that last week. It was very challenging for a lot of folks. But yeah, I recorded this interview last week while Abbie was traveling and I'm excited to share it with you. After we share the interview, Abbie and I will talk about our key takeaways, and then we're going to cover some breaking fitness news in our first-ever Cool Down segment. See, it's the opposite of the warm-up: we're doing some fitness news in the cooldown. Get it?

Abbie: Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's not a difficult concept to wrap your head around, babes.

Alex: All right. Well, let's get to that Jake Remmert interview.

Interview: Jake Remmert

Alex: Jake Remmert holds a PhD in integrative biology, a fancy term for exercise physiology, from Florida Atlantic University, and is a certified strength and conditioning specialist. He's currently a tenure-track professor and researcher at Illinois State University, and his research focuses on optimizing training and nutritional variables for maximal hypertrophy, strength, and fat loss. Jake is also a powerlifter and bodybuilder and provides one-on-one coaching for a variety of clients. You can check out his website at jakeremmert.com. Jake, welcome to Practically Fit.

Jake: Thank you so much, man. I'm honored to be here. I appreciate the invite, and I think this will be really fun.

From Instagram to a PhD

Alex: Yeah, I want to talk about this recent study that you were the lead author on. But before we do that, let's talk about your background, because I found it really fascinating. You're a researcher, but you're also a powerlifter. So tell us how you discovered your love for strength training and how you became a researcher.

Jake: Yeah. They kind of happened hand in hand, funny enough. When I first got into fitness in general, I just wanted to get a little healthier, build a little muscle, lose a little body fat, whatever. And as you do, you start scrolling on Instagram to find somebody to get information from, right?

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: This was, when was this, 2013, 2014, something like that. I was fortunate to find some really good evidence-based people immediately. One of those was a guy named Layne Norton, whom most people have probably at least heard of, or heard of his company, BioLayne. He has a PhD, and he's instrumental in really building the wave of people who are interested in lifting weights but then go get a degree in lifting weights, basically. That was really inspiring to me, and I followed him really closely. He's the one who got me interested in powerlifting, really. I got bit by the bug pretty quickly and powerlifted, only powerlifted, for probably four or five years. Then I tried the bodybuilding thing, and to be honest, I've been doing that since. I haven't competed in powerlifting since 2019, so it's been a minute. It feels weird that it's been that long now. I have said that I will go back at some point, and I'll stand by that, but I just don't know when that'll be, because the bodybuilding-style training is a little bit faster these days. The time efficiency is nice. But yeah, I really dove into training and tried to learn as much as I could about it. Like I said, I found these guys like Layne, and I was like, wow, okay, you can get a degree in this. This is cool. And I would love to be an online coach. How do I stand out? Oh, I guess I'll go get a PhD.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: Which is so silly. But it worked out. We did it, and it sort of worked in a weird way. And luckily, along the way I found out that I do, in fact, love research, and love mentoring students and doing all that stuff too. So it's cool that I've somehow landed in a space where I get to do all of those things.

Alex: Oh, very good. It's amazing, doing what you love. That's so cool.

The Study: How Many Sets Per Workout?

Alex: Well, I saw your recent study in some media coverage. The study was titled "Is There Too Much of a Good Thing? Meta-Regressions of the Effect of Per-Session Volume on Hypertrophy and Strength." This was a meta-analysis, so it examined data from nearly 70 studies and more than 2,000 participants to find out how many sets per workout it takes to build muscle and strength, which is really cool. The study has gotten some media attention, and I found the findings fascinating. So at a high level, talk to us about how you conducted the study and what you found.

Jake: Yeah, totally. We, as a lab, it was five of us in total: four students, and then the PI, the principal investigator who runs the lab, Dr. Zourdos. All of us were trying to decide what project to do, and we landed on this, which was a much bigger undertaking than I originally thought it would be, but I learned a ton. What we did is we went through all the studies that manipulated either volume or frequency or both, because volume and frequency together is how you get the per-session volume, right? How you split it across the week. It was such a process, man, going through and systematically choosing which studies to include; they call it screening. We wound up with, I think, 67 studies by the end. The purpose of this, as you said, was to get at that idea of per-session volume, which didn't have very much research on it at all. There's a bunch of stuff on weekly volume, a lot of individual studies and a few meta-analyses. There's stuff on frequency, but not much on per session. There are a couple of things, but not a ton. So we really wanted to get in there and update our understanding of that. It was hand in hand with the rest of my dissertation, which was focused on fine-tuning per-session volume. So that was the goal. And with any meta-analysis, all you're doing, quote-unquote, is really closely reading all the papers, pulling out all of the necessary information, doing the new stats on everything as a whole, and then you get the output, and you spend weeks trying to make sense of it before you can write the paper, right? But we got there eventually and found some really interesting things. I can talk about the methods in more detail if you want, but I don't know how granular you want me to get. Some of that gets a little lost in the weeds.

Alex: Yeah, I think just explain it in a way that our listeners can understand. We're curious to hear about the results of the study.

Jake: Cool. The results, to me, are fascinating in some ways, and there's one limitation on the strength stuff that I always try to mention. For muscle growth, we found that in general, the more volume you do in a workout, the more muscle growth you're going to get. And we compared different ways to quantify how many sets you're doing. In the past, what most studies do is what we call total sets. The easy example to illustrate is bicep growth. They would say, if you do anything that works your biceps, that counts. So if you do bicep curls and you do lat pulldowns, those both count equally. And we were like, man, I don't know. It really doesn't seem like lat pulldowns grow your arms as much. So we were trying to get at this idea that it does something, but not as much. We analyzed it that way, counting them the same, and then we also analyzed it in what we called fractional sets, which counted the lat pulldowns in that example as half a set. That half value was arbitrary, right? You could make an argument that it should have been 0.3 or 0.6 or 0.4175, whatever. But you've got to pick something. And we were able to compare which of those quantification methods fit the data best, and we found the fractional was the best, which is cool, because that reflects what we seem to see in practice, right? Those indirect sets—

Alex: Exactly. For anybody who's ever lifted weights, that totally makes sense to me.

Jake: 100%. So that was cool to see. Like I said, we found that in general, more sets per session leads to more growth, but it does taper off. If you look at the paper, there's a nice green graph that you can see. It's very much what we call a logarithmic curve, where those first few sets give really quick, robust muscle growth, and then with each additional set you get less and less of a return. Diminishing returns. If you think back to your high school math class, it approaches an asymptote, right? It really levels off. It never comes back down, at least based on the data we had, but it really levels off. So I wanted to find, well, man, what's the number of sets where it's really hard to justify doing more? In the paper we call it the PUOS, the point of undetectable outcome superiority. I'm sorry I couldn't come up with a better term than that. It's a mouthful. Essentially, there's another meta-analysis from a researcher named James Steele, who's highly regarded in the field, and he looked at what the normal variance is that we might expect in resistance training research, with a huge data set. So we used that and compared the additional muscle growth you might see from each additional set against that normal variation. So, for example, if set number three gives you an additional two percent of muscle size, and our normal variation is one percent, cool, we're confident that's a real change, probably worth doing. But as you do more and more sets, we get smaller and smaller returns, right? We defined the PUOS as the point where the additional growth has a less than 50% probability of exceeding the variation. I know that sounds pedantic and annoying, but that's just how these statistical models work. It's all probabilities. Nonetheless, it's right around 11 fractional sets per workout, which is quite a bit. Some people do that much volume, and some people do more than that, but for a lot of people, we don't really need to worry too much about going above that most of the time.

The other thing I like to say is to remember that's fractional sets. That's not necessarily doing 11 sets of biceps. If you do eight sets of back using our method, that's four that count toward the biceps already, that sort of thing. But for some muscles, like the back or the chest, you don't really get much indirect work. So we did a conversion in the paper as well, and it's right around eight or so, where you're kind of tapping that out. So when I'm giving a practical recommendation based on what we found, I say eight to ten, eight to twelve sets is the top end of what I would feel comfortable recommending for people. That's not to say you can't go more than that if you're trying to get on the Mr. Olympia stage.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: Or you might want to do more than that just to be safe, or at least go really high on the top end, because it's worth the extra fatigue for that tiny little bit extra. For most of us, it's not worth it. But that's the top end we were looking at, right around 11 fractional sets. The other thing to point out is that if you look at that curve, those first few sets have a much steeper slope. It's a much faster increase in muscle growth before it tapers off. So you can look at that and make a really strong argument, I think, for why not do more sessions per week with fewer sets per workout and take advantage of the faster, more efficient gains from those first few sets. The data we have, the meta-analyses we did, do not suggest that that is better. They don't say it's worse. They just don't say it's better. That being said, I can look at the curve, and it makes a whole lot of sense to me to do that too. So as we get more and more research over the next however many years, we may find that, rather than getting up to eight, nine, ten, eleven sets, maybe we say let's get up to five or six or something like that, and just do it more frequently. Maybe. I don't know. But there are your caveats on all that stuff.

What It Means for People Over 40

Alex: That's really interesting. I want to jump in on that. I was going to ask you about the implications for people over 40, because that's the main audience for our podcast. When you start talking about the benefit from five to six sets, I wonder: are these lower-volume workouts a viable option to maintain strength as you age?

Jake: 100%. And I think the older we get, the more fatigue is the thing we really want to pay attention to, right? When we're 18, it kind of doesn't matter. Just go in and do a lot of stuff and you'll be fine. But as we get older, we've got to really start to pay attention. So it starts to feel less and less worth it to push those really high volumes when you know you're getting such a tiny return on your big investment. For some people it's still super worth it, and that's awesome. But I think for most people, it makes the most sense to stay on the lower end and prioritize how you're feeling. The sustainability of what you're doing is massive. And you mentioned strength. The strength results are interesting. If anyone's looking at the paper, this is the purple graph. Same thing: more sets lead to more strength gains, but it tapers off quick, much quicker than the muscle growth.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: We found that two sets in a workout is kind of the top end there, which I think makes sense, that it's lower than the muscle growth, right? Strength training, heavier weights, lower reps, just beats you up more. We're just not going to do as much. One big limitation I always like to point out with this, and we have it in the paper too, towards the end: the average rep range of all the studies we included in the analysis was about nine reps per set, which is not super specific for strength, right? Most people are doing sets of five, sets of six, sets of three, whatever. So my guess, if I combine my coaching experience with this, is that had the training programs in these studies used heavier weights on average, I think we would see a benefit from slightly higher set numbers per workout.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: I don't know how much higher. I don't think it's going to be 11, but I think it's probably a little more than two, probably somewhere in that middle ground. And that lines up with my coaching experience. With most clients I've worked with, when we're making the best progress, and it depends on the person, of course, it's usually somewhere around, I don't know, three to six sets in a workout, something like that on average. So—

Alex: Awesome. Well, as a strength and conditioning coach, we talked a little about lower-volume workouts for people over 40. What's your main advice for folks over 40 on maintaining strength as they age? And if they want muscle growth too, cool. What are your thoughts on that?

Jake: Yeah, honestly, I think my main advice is: stay healthy. As we age and as we get stronger and stronger, I think it's sort of the same advice for both. The fatigue starts to matter a whole lot more, and we just have to stay healthy, because that's the only way we're going to make progress, if we can stay in the gym. If we're constantly going, oh, my knee hurts, oh, my shoulder hurts, my back, that's just a bummer. We're not going to be able to be in there working as hard as we'd like to and maintaining, or hopefully even gaining, strength year to year. So that's what I would say. The best way to stay healthy is, of course, to make sure your technique is solid.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: That should be a given. Make sure the quality's there. Try to stay on top of your sleep, and don't be eating 500 calories a day and that's it; try to make intelligent choices there. But with the training program, the biggest thing is just don't be too ambitious. Make sure we're being realistic with what is sustainable for us. Take advantage of the results from this sort of study, where we can see, man, those early sets are where most of the benefit is anyway.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: Let's take advantage of that. Keep our volume manageable, and watch our subjective recovery, just how you feel. But also look at your training performance. If it's really stagnant, or especially if it's going down, that's not the best sign for your recovery, and we probably want to see if we can tinker with something. And if we're steadily increasing a little bit and doing the progressive overload thing, then you're probably in pretty good shape.

Coaching With Emotional Intelligence

Alex: Awesome. Well, tell us more about your approach to coaching. I noticed that in your bio you mention incorporating emotional intelligence into your coaching. I found that intriguing. How do you do that, and why is it so important?

Jake: Yeah, well, I think it's important because it's sort of all I know, to be honest. When I got my coach, oh geez, when was that? 2017, I think. I've been on and off with him a little bit since then, but he's the only coach I've ever had. His name's Ryan Doris.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: He really knows his stuff with training and nutrition, but what drew me to him was his emotional intelligence and how he approached things. He takes a very philosophical, psychological, emotional approach to a lot of this, to really get to know somebody and help them stop self-sabotaging, stop getting in their own way, and figure out how to actually do the stuff they're trying to get themselves to do.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: He obviously was a great coach, but he quickly became a mentor and like a big brother to me. I learned so much from him, and I don't know how to coach any other way than that. So I do video check-ins with my clients, where they record their update and send it to me so I can sort of look them in the eye. Schedules are crazy for people, and synchronous calls all the time aren't realistic, I don't think. But being able to see their facial expression, their tone of voice, that kind of stuff really helps. You just get more information, and I get that from having conversations with them. I'm not the kind of coach who says, you can send me a message on check-in day, and that's it. That's just not my thing. I want to build a relationship. As corny as it is, the coolest part of this job is that you make friends with people. It genuinely is the coolest part. And not only for that, just for the sake of it, but you're a much more effective pair when you're both on the same wavelength. You feel more open with each other, you're more able to be honest, and they feel more comfortable sharing what they're struggling with. I feel more comfortable being like, hey, dude, no disrespect, but we've got to do this better, or whatever. We can have those open, honest conversations, and we can really tailor the program, not just on the physiology side with the X's and O's, but: how do we actually make this work for somebody in their life, and not just be this stressful thing? So I think it's super important. And it's a two-way street. Not everybody you work with wants that out of coaching, which is fine. Some people just want a program, and they go execute it, and that's great. But when you get somebody who will invest in you as well, man, it's cool, and you can really do some good stuff.

Goal Setting: Process Over Numbers

Alex: Yeah, and you're building trust with that relationship. That's awesome. One of the topics we've covered often on the podcast is goal setting and motivation. So talk to us about that. How do you help your clients set realistic and achievable fitness goals, and what do you find motivates people to stay active? I know you can't paint everybody with a broad brush, but what trends have you seen in your coaching?

Jake: Yeah, that's a great question. One of the things I like to do with goal setting is try to shift away from "I really want to bench two plates" or "I really want to squat three," whatever the number is. We all have those numbers. I have those numbers.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: That's part of why I say I want to go back to powerlifting, because I never hit some of those. But I think the best thing we can do is have process-oriented goals. I am a gigantic nerd, okay? I love fantasy and science fiction and all this stuff, and one of my favorite authors is a guy named Brandon Sanderson. He talks a lot about this idea that if he tried to write one of these thousand-page books that he writes, and he's just like, I'm going to write a thousand-page book, he would fall off immediately. He wouldn't be able to do it. But if he says, I'm going to write today for a couple of hours, he can do that. He just builds those wins, and along the way you're just doing the process day to day, and eventually you write the thousand-page book. I think fitness is the same way. Rather than saying, I really want to bench this much, or deadlift this much, or run this distance in this time, how do we make our goals about the process itself? My goal is to show up to the gym and execute my workout. My goal is to get my protein in at every meal. My goal is to complete this diet without my spouse hating me because I'm miserable and hungry and annoying, and all these things. How do we do the little day-to-day stuff that eventually leads to the thing? How do we get ourselves to do the things our future self will thank us for? That's how I try to reframe some of this. It doesn't always work. Especially younger people usually get hung up on the numbers, which, again, I've been there.

Alex: Yeah. As a competitive person, this really resonates with me, because I know that as I age I have to adjust the way I think about goal setting. So I think that's a really cool approach. I actually saw a study last week that said competitiveness peaks at age 50. So there you go.

Jake: Okay, cool. There you go.

Alex: Well, you've competed in bodybuilding and powerlifting. Does active participation in those sports give you unique insights into your research?

Jake: Oh, totally. This is what's so cool about this job, man: me doing the sports and training myself, coaching, and doing the research and teaching. The classes I teach, I'm literally talking about some of my own research from my PhD in there. It's cool.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: They all feed into each other. You'll be going through something in your own training, and then you're working with a client, and now I have that firsthand experience I can draw from to help them through it. Or maybe we have a question, like, there's no answer to this, how do I program, how do I solve this problem? Wish there was a study. Oh, wait, now I can do that study. That's super cool. So now I get these, dare I say, cutting-edge study ideas for lack of a better term. It's never hard to come up with ideas I want to do. Sometimes putting those ideas into practice gets tricky because there are limitations to time and money for a lab. But there's no shortage of ideas. And it works the other way too: you do stuff in the lab and you learn things you want to implement in what you do, and I have the benefit of not having to wait until it's publicly available for everybody. I just know what they are already, so I can apply it early. They all feed into each other. It's pretty cool.

What's Next, and the Smith Machine

Alex: That's awesome. Well, Jake, thanks for nerding out with us on your research today. I'm curious: in terms of your research, what's next?

Jake: Oh man. I'm currently working on a couple of things. My big pie-in-the-sky thing that I want to do within the next couple of years is looking at the rate of weight gain and how that impacts muscle growth and fat gain along the way, trying to find that optimal, quote-unquote, loaded-term rate of weight gain that avoids some of that extra fat gain but still maxes out our muscle growth. But that's a big project, so I need some smaller things first. Some of the stuff I'm looking at now, on one hand, is something called interoception, which is sort of your ability to listen to your internal bodily cues, to be in tune with your body and how you're feeling and what you're doing. I think that is closely tied to some of the stuff we do in the gym. You're doing a set of whatever exercise: how close to failure are you? On average, people are pretty good at judging that, but some people are better than others. Why is that? Maybe it's because of this. Or even beyond training: how in tune are you with your normal hunger and fullness cues? I think that's interesting.

And then on the other side, in a completely different area than anything I've ever done before, which has been a lot of reading and a lot of learning, I'm looking at some of the neuromuscular electrical stimulation stuff. You can electrically stimulate a muscle to contract, right? You just give a little shock. I'm looking at how some of the fatigue dynamics work: you do some sort of protocol, you try to contract the muscle as hard as you can and produce as much force as you can. That is somewhat tied to your ability to try really hard, which is somewhat psychological and all these things.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: Whereas if we just shock the muscle, it doesn't matter. If you're mentally tired, it'll just contract really hard. So there's a disconnect there, and that disconnect is a really interesting way to parse apart what we call central fatigue versus peripheral fatigue. Central fatigue is like, you do this really hard set and you're like, oof, I can't even blink, what's happening? Your body just feels trashed.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: Peripheral fatigue would be, you do a set of bicep curls to failure or whatever, and you feel fine, but your biceps are fried. Those are different kinds of fatigue, and we just don't know much about fatigue in general as a field. So we're trying to find some ways to look at that, and I think it'll be a really interesting place to go. I'm learning a lot, and soon I'm going to be the guinea pig who gets to shock himself a million times to figure out how the machine works before I use it on anyone else.

Alex: Hey, also, one-arm push-ups will do that too.

Jake: Exactly right.

Alex: Yeah, that's crazy. Really fascinating. Well, Jake, I want to finish off with a fun question. What's the one strength exercise you can't live without? We all have one. What's yours?

Jake: Oh. Squatting in the Smith machine.

Alex: Yeah. Interesting.

Jake: I love it. I powerlifted for so long, so all my powerlifter friends laughed at me when I started doing it.

Alex: Yeah.

Jake: But man, my ankle mobility is not very good. My hip mobility is not very good. I can just hop in the Smith machine and do fine. I don't have to spend 45 minutes warming up anymore, and that's pretty nice.

Alex: That's awesome. Well, cool. Thanks for sharing that with us, and thanks again for joining the show. If you'd like to learn more about Jake's research or his one-on-one coaching, which sounds like an amazing approach, head on over to jakeremmert.com. Jake, thanks for joining Practically Fit.

Jake: Thank you.

Our Takeaways

Alex: Well, there you have it: the interview with researcher Jake Remmert from Illinois State University. Abbie, I had a couple of big takeaways from the interview that I'd like to share. The first was really focused on Jake's study. A lot of the gains you accrue as part of your strength training occur in the first few sets. It was really cool to hear him talk about how this information might apply for people over 40. I think it's really important to emphasize the quality of your sets up front, really being locked in and focused on those initial sets. Talking to him about what they saw in the research really got me thinking about focusing on form when you're lifting weights or doing strength training, to maximize those strength and muscle gains.

Abbie: Yeah, I thought that was really interesting too, Alex. I think both of us naturally lean this way, but it made me think about the exercises you want to put at the beginning of your workout. It re-emphasized for me that if I'm really wanting to work hard in an area, I should make sure that's at the beginning of my workout.

Alex: Yeah. For me, doing core lifts up front is really important, like squats or bench press, the big lifts, and then you do those supporting lifts that he talked about. I also thought it was interesting that the gains do tail off as you add sets, which is somewhat intuitive, but also that you do continue to make gains with the extra sets. So the implication for people who are aging is that while you want a good number of sets in your strength workout, you may not need as many as you think, and you might even benefit from spacing out the volume more over the week. This is something I've been doing recently in my workouts. I've talked a lot about my love for calisthenics, but recently I've gone back to lifting weights, and I've been doing total-body workouts three times a week. Squats are a great example: I try to do those two to three times a week, and I can spread out the volume. Something I really enjoy doing with squats, because I think it's a really challenging exercise that challenges your central nervous system in addition to your overall strength, is to do a warm-up and then do single reps, squat singles, and work my way up the ladder. That's an approach I really enjoy with that particular exercise, and then I can spread it out over the week. Something about that has just worked for me over the years. So I thought it was cool hearing about Jake's study.

Abbie: Yeah, totally agree. I thought that was really interesting, and it makes you think about how you plan across the week in terms of your approach.

Alex: Yeah. I also really love what he said about setting process-oriented goals. This was my second big takeaway, and honestly, it blew me away. For me, it's a totally different mindset from how I think about goals, and it connects beautifully to last week's episode about mitigating your competitive instincts as you age. If you haven't listened to that, check it out; it's a really nice tie-in. This idea of reframing your goals away from chasing numbers on a bench press or squat, like he talked about, to just getting in, doing the work, completing your workouts, and eating healthy sounds like a pretty powerful way to approach goal setting.

Abbie: Yeah, this one really stood out to me too, Alex. It's interesting, because at work we've been talking about the opposite: outcome focus, how you get laser focus on the outcome you're driving toward, especially because we were thinking about long-term impact.

Alex: Right.

Abbie: But what I really liked about this, and it really spoke to me, was sitting in the moment. He was talking about focusing the workout on the process itself, and to me the sense was: detach from the outcome, because that can feel a little overwhelming. How do you break it down into smaller chunks so you're not getting so focused on the outcome? I thought that was really interesting, because right now I'm training for a half marathon, and you tend to hyper-focus on the race, rather than sitting in the moment and thinking about what I'm doing today. I thought it was very grounding: be present in the moment, think about the process, and focus a little less on the outcome, which can sometimes cause you to do things just because you're focused on that outcome. For example, today I had an 11-mile run on the plan. But as Alex mentioned, I've been traveling all week, a really busy, hectic week, very tired, very overloaded. An 11-mile run actually wasn't right for me today.

Alex: So—

Abbie: So it was good. I reframed my run into something where I was practicing higher pacing, and I felt really good at the end of the run. I felt really in the moment, and I felt really proud of myself. So I think that's a really beautiful framing, and it really spoke to me too.

Alex: Yeah. Well, Abbie, what other takeaways did you have from the interview?

Abbie: Yeah, there were two additional ones that I really liked. The first was, it sounds so simple, but staying healthy. I thought that was a really great point he made: sometimes you can get so focused on progression and chasing these big goals, but actually the most important thing is consistency. So staying healthy so you can actually work out three times a week, rather than chasing big numbers or progression. I thought that was really meaningful, and I really liked that he said it.

Alex: Yeah, that is good advice. I think, especially for folks over 40 and 50 as you're aging, staying healthy, like he was talking about, can be a powerful thing to think about. It goes along with the motivation piece, too. We talk about intrinsic motivation, and staying healthy is really an intrinsic motivation to pair with those process-oriented goals.

Abbie: Yeah, it really spoke to me. He said, if you're pushing yourself too hard and you end up with a knee injury or this, that, or the other, and then you can't work out at all. I thought that was really good advice. And the second one I really liked was the piece on emotional intelligence, because I haven't necessarily heard that talked about so much by a physical fitness trainer, but it really spoke to me, and I feel like it's very in tune with how I think. If I go way back, when I was younger I was a horse rider, and I've actually been saying to Alex recently, and I don't know whether it's nostalgia or the age that I am, that I want to get back into horse riding. The instructor I had who worked best with me had really high EQ, and it made such a massive difference. I progressed under her by leaps and bounds compared to the prior instructor, who barked orders at me, and I just didn't feel attuned to. So I really loved that in terms of thinking about, if you're looking for a personal trainer or just an accountability buddy, how you find somebody who's really in tune with you from an emotional intelligence perspective. And what I really liked is that this wasn't about being gentle with somebody. It was also about having the kind of relationship where you can call somebody out and hold them to account, but you're really in tune with them from that EQ perspective.

Alex: Yeah, building trust helps you have those difficult conversations when you need to have them. I thought that was amazing as well. Just overall, really great.

Abbie: Oh, he was amazing, such a great interview. I really loved that somebody with a PhD who has that depth of knowledge and data was so easy to understand.

Alex: Yeah, amazing interview. So thanks again to Jake for joining Practically Fit. Maybe we'll have you on again in the future when you have some new research to share.

The Cool Down: Brain Stacking

Alex: Well, with that, we're going to transition to the world of fitness news. We have a couple of stories to share this week. The first one comes from The New York Times, and honestly, we had to do the Cool Down just based on this story alone. It's titled "Doomscrolling? Try Brain Stacking." As soon as I saw this headline, I was already getting analog-backpack vibes from the article. I'll just share the lead with you now, Abbie. The article says, quote: "Hannah Busby was beginning to feel like her day job as a creative content strategist was draining her energy." Hannah, I feel you on that. "And when she came home feeling burned out, she spent evenings locked in an endless doomscroll, which certainly did not help. Then she tried something less intimidating than, say, an hours-long craft project or an expensive class: one hour each day with a sequence of timed activities. She and others call it brain stacking, which meshes together several ideas about habit formation. For her, it looked like one page's worth of journaling, 15 minutes of sudoku, and 30 minutes of reading. She is part of an online trend, ironically, to get offline and do enriching, low-effort activities."

Abbie: I love the principle of what this is talking about, of doing some things that are different from what you're doing during the day. Get away from looking at a computer, do things for your brain. But why, A, does it have to be branded as something? My stepdad has been doing sudoku for years. He doesn't call it brain stacking. My parents did this every night. He just does sudoku. And also, why does it then have to be put online? It just feels like an influencer strategy.

Alex: Yeah. Well, the article says Busby has grown an audience on social media by sharing time-lapse videos of her brain-stacking activities, with many of her viewers putting their own spin on it, with activities that suit their personal interests. It's like folks are just doing normal activities, like we said, the things our parents did every night. Abbie, you do puzzles every night. I have a physical newspaper subscription to USA Today, so you can do the puzzles from there. We do Wordle.

Abbie: I know, and I don't sit here going, Alex, I am now transitioning to my hour of brain stacking.

Alex: Yeah, and I read the physical newspaper because it relaxes me. So, same thing. Like you said, it doesn't have to be relabeled or repackaged and branded as some mind-blowing discovery. And we're not trying to be critical. I just had a visceral reaction when I read this article. It's like, oh my gosh, who knew that reading and doing puzzles might help your brain and mitigate stress? These are just normal activities. Why do we have to optimize activities like journaling and reading? I think that's what it is for me, in the culture right now: this idea of optimizing everything. There are all kinds of different types of "maxing"; they're putting the word "maxing" after things now. I think that's what's driving me crazy about this.

Abbie: Yeah, because in principle, the thing itself is great, and we should encourage people to do these things. There's lots of really great research about things like sudoku being good for the longevity of a healthy brain and helping you avoid things like Alzheimer's. So great, great, great. I also just really struggle with the hundreds of thousands of videos of people talking about it.

Alex: Right. Well, the article says, quote: "Hundreds of TikTok and Instagram videos show people setting the mood for brain stacking by lighting a candle, then piling actual stacks of activities, spiral notebooks on top of murder-mystery-themed logic and math-based puzzle books atop customized journals, novels, and e-readers into a neat pyramid. They unpack specialty pens and pencils from colorful zippered pouches or select them from ornate glass jars."

Abbie: I mean, that just gives me anxiety.

Alex: Yeah, well, that's an interesting thing; we'll talk more about that in a moment. The article goes on to quote some experts on why these basic things that people have been doing for centuries are good. And it talks about Amanda Sneed. She's 28, and apparently she's helped popularize this trend by filming videos from the public library in Valparaiso, Indiana. Shout-out to Valparaiso; my mom used to work at that university there. Amanda says, quote: "My dad taught me sudoku in elementary school, and I've been keeping journals since I could write. So it was already part of my routine. It just wasn't filmed and optimized all at once." And her stack often includes her bedazzled leather-bound journals and some knitting and crochet exercises. Abbie, I've got to ask you: haven't females been decorating their journals for decades?

Abbie: Great point, Alex. I remember back in senior school, I would cover my notebooks for my different classes in greeting paper or stickers or all kinds of things. Our kids do the same. I know they've got different stickers on stuff; they've decorated their laptops. It's the same thing.

Alex: And I don't say that to be gender-stereotypical. I just remember girls doing that back when I was in school. So again, it's nothing against people doing these activities. I'm glad people are doing these things as opposed to doomscrolling. I think it's a natural reaction to social media and how overly electronified everything has become, and people are starting to realize the negative effects from a mental health perspective. But I think there's an irony that people who claim to be optimizing these offline activities are then chronicling it all online and building a following like they've discovered something revolutionary. And again, this idea that everything has to be optimized and stacked. Can you just not take some quiet time to do the activity? Like you said earlier, I'm starting to theorize that the obsession with optimizing everything might take away from the desired effect you're trying to achieve by doing offline activities. If you're so focused on, I have to do this for a specific amount of time, I have to do this many things, it almost seems kind of stressful, which is the opposite of what you're trying to achieve.

Abbie: No, I completely agree. I think it makes everything feel like something you have to keep up with, right? Social media is fine if you do it in moderation; all of these things are fine. I just feel like it creates this really unhealthy dynamic, and I worry about the impact of that. It's great to do crafting and journaling as long as it works for you. For some people it might not be a great thing. For example, I find knitting really stressful. I'm not good at it, and I find it super stressful. But there are other things that I find really relaxing, so it's just about finding those things and not having to put it online or declare it to the world.

Alex: Right. And for heaven's sake, we're doing a podcast, it's posted online, and we do social media videos and all that, so we've got no problem with that. It's just, I don't know. I found this article fascinating and indicative of the culture right now, so I wanted to share it.

The Cool Down: Josh Kerr on Hydration Vests and Shoes

Alex: The second article we have comes from Abbie's favorite publication, Canadian Running.

Abbie: I've never read Canadian Running, babes. You love these niche publications. Although, I mean, there must be a lot of runners in Canada.

Alex: Well, I just thought you'd like it because it's part of the Commonwealth.

Abbie: I also love Canada.

Alex: Yeah, there you go. The title of the article is "Josh Kerr Has Advice for Recreational Runners: Ditch the Hydration Vest." This is one I saw on Reddit the other day, and I wanted to share it because it caused some debate on Reddit. Josh Kerr is an Olympic miler from Great Britain, and if you're not familiar with him, there was a video circulating a few months ago. He broke the world record in the mile, which, off the top of my head, I think had stood for 20 years. He ran the mile in three minutes and 42 seconds, which is just phenomenal. If you're a runner and you think about what that requires, that's incredible. A lot of the article focused on his running and rivalries with other athletes, but it was actually based on an AMA, an Ask Me Anything, that he did on Reddit. As part of that, he gave some advice to recreational runners. The article says, quote, "In one of the more relatable parts of the AMA, Kerr weighed in on some running trends, including the growing popularity of hydration vests." And this is why I wanted to bring this up, Abbie, because we both have hydration vests. You're a big hydration vest fan. Josh Kerr said, quote, "I'd say that if you're running less than 12 miles, you probably don't need to bring water bottles with you." He acknowledged that runners have different needs and reasons for carrying water, but suggested that hydration while running is sometimes overdone, particularly in urban environments where runners can easily stop and purchase a drink. Abbie, what do we think about that? Do you think you need to bring hydration with you if you're running less than 12 miles?

Abbie: I think I personally reacted badly to this, because I don't think there should be any judgment. If you want to run with a hydration vest, who are you hurting? If that works for you, you should do it. I know people who run with a hydration vest on a 5K, and if that makes them feel good and supported, why are we judging it? Also, this is from a guy who runs the mile. How often does he run a— I don't know.

Alex: He said he wants to do the marathon, in the article.

Abbie: Okay, fine. But still, I just don't think we should judge people for something like that. I get what he's saying, that you can stop to buy drinks, but have you ever stopped partway through a 12-mile run and gone into a 7-Eleven to buy a drink? It's more than a couple of minutes' stop.

Alex: So you're going to pound an entire Gatorade while you're at 7-Eleven? Or you're going to carry your drink.

Abbie: It's super impractical. I also personally like to have a hydration vest with me, and there's something about it that makes me feel, what's the right word, like I've got everything I need, even if I don't use it. Psychologically, that's really helpful for me. I have water, I have these things, and I'm not going to worry about the fact that I might not be able to stop or might not find somewhere. So I think it's a little impractical to say that, and it means you're not running continuously. Whereas if you have a hydration vest, you literally don't need to stop.

Alex: Right. Well, you know what I immediately thought about when I read this? I was just like, where do you live? I mean, I guess he lives in Great Britain. That is a dumb thing to say. But okay, great, you live in Great Britain.

Abbie: Or you live in London and you're running around an urban environment. But even some urban environments doesn't mean you can easily go somewhere to buy hydration.

Alex: Well, it's not even that. I'm talking about climate. We live in Texas, and many, many months out of the year, it's very warm.

Abbie: You couldn't even run a 5K without hydration.

Alex: It's very dependent on the time of year and where you live, I think, to make a statement like this. So yeah, it was getting a lot of attention online. I'll give you an example from this week. We had amazing weather here, fall weather in Texas, in the 50s. It was a little bit cooler today when you ran. I ran yesterday, around 50 degrees, cloudy. I did a 10K and I did not need hydration with me. I wasn't planning on running that far, but I just got out and it felt so amazing. But if I'd done that in a warmer part of the year, I would definitely need hydration. Usually for me, if it's less than five miles in Texas, I'm good, but anything more than that, especially when it's warm, you definitely need the hydration here.

Abbie: I also use my hydration vest for more than just water. I carry my phone, and you can put a layer into it that you can take off. So it's more than just about having water. But like I said, I would just encourage us not to judge people. Why does it matter? And especially for recreational runners, what difference is it making?

Alex: Right. Well, he also waded into the carbon-plated racing shoe debate. He encouraged recreational runners to rotate their shoes instead of relying on carbon-plated racing shoes for training, which I think is good advice in that sense.

Abbie: Yeah, I do. Although I was like, well, you could be doing both at the same time, right? You could be rotating your shoes and still using carbon-plated racing shoes during races.

Alex: There is a lot of research that shows that for recreational runners, it's not really making that much of a difference. That said, the shoe I've been wearing all the time recently has a carbon plate, and I wear them almost every time I run. So yeah, I think he's right, but I didn't have a strong reaction to this. I know a lot of people do, though.

Abbie: Yeah, I agree with you, Alex. There's probably minimal evidence, and I would say just make sure you're not causing yourself any issues by running in carbon-plated shoes. There's some evidence about the impact that has on your system and so on.

Alex: Yeah, it depends on how comfortable the shoes are, I think. So shout-out to Saucony. He also recommended incorporating some strength training barefoot, to avoid becoming too accustomed to super-cushioned shoes. I don't know if you've ever tried to work out with weights in super shoes. If people are doing that, he's definitely giving you some good advice here, because I would not try to do squats in current-day running shoes; you'll tip over. It's not safe, in my opinion. But I did think this was good advice. I sometimes will train barefoot with kettlebells or even squats. I've done barefoot barbell squats, and it does help your feet, I think. So I thought that was good.

Abbie: Yeah. I often do an entire weight workout barefoot, because I had read some information about it being good for your overall form and also giving your feet a break from that cushioning.

Alex: Yeah. The one thing for me, though, is that some exercises just make me nervous without shoes on, like if you're using heavy dumbbells. I guess if you drop a weight on your foot, you're probably—

Abbie: I mean, I don't know how your shoes would protect you. If you're going to drop a heavy dumbbell on your foot, it's going to hurt you regardless of whether you've got a shoe on.

Alex: Yeah, it's just the idea that there's nothing over my foot protecting it at all. It still seems better to have a shoe on if I drop a 50-pound dumbbell on my foot. But anyway, interesting advice from this runner, and I enjoyed reading the article. It generated a lot of discussion on Reddit. So there you go. That's this week's edition of the Cool Down.

Wrap-Up

Abbie: Well, that's it for this week's edition of the podcast. We hope you enjoyed it, and we hope you took some valuable information from the interview with Jake. We'd love for you to join us next week when we take a trip down fitness memory lane and talk about our favorite fitness memories. As always, if you enjoyed this episode, please leave us a review on your favorite podcast platform. And if you've got a question or comment or suggestion, please send us an email at alex@practically.fit.

Alex: That's right, Abbie. And remember, when it comes to fitness, you don't have to be perfect, you just have to be practical. We'll catch you on the next one.